Sense and denotation as algorithm and value
نویسنده
چکیده
In his classic 1892 paper On sense and denotation [12], Frege first contends that in addition to their denotation (reference, Bedeutung), proper names also have a sense (Sinn) “wherein the mode of presentation [of the denotation] is contained.” Here proper names include common nouns like “the earth” or “Odysseus” and descriptive phrases like “the point of intersection of lines L1 and L2” which are expected by their grammatical form to name some object. By the second fundamental doctrine introduced by Frege in the same paper, they also include declarative sentences: “[a simple, assertoric sentence is] to be regarded as a proper name, and its denotation, if it has one, is either the True or the False.” Thus every sentence denotes (or refers to) its truth value and expresses its sense, which is “a mode of presentation” of its truth value: this is all there is to the meaning of a sentence as far as logic is concerned. Finally, Frege claims that although sense and denotation are related (the first determines the second), they obey separate principles of compositionality, so that the truth value of a complex sentence φ is determined solely by the denotations of its constituent parts (terms and sentences), whatever the senses of these constituents parts may be. This is the basic principle which has made possible the development of sense-independent (two-valued, classical) denotational semantics for predicate logic, a variety of richer formal languages and (at least) fragments of natural language. Consider, for example, the arithmetical sentences
منابع مشابه
Denotation by Sense and Reference
The notion of reference as entailment in the common ground provides a uniied framework for the treatment of denotation by names, deenite descriptions, and pronouns, including anaphors. Within this framework, semantic and pragmatic considerations are combined, giving two kinds of proof of denotation, by sense and by reference, for references to individuals which are and aren't already in the com...
متن کاملThe senses of functions in the Logic of Sense and Denotation
This paper discusses certain problems arising within the treatment of the senses of functions in Alonzo Church’s Logic of Sense and Denotation. Church understands such senses themselves to be “sense-functions,” functions from sense to sense. However, the conditions he lays out under which a sense-function is to be regarded as a sense presenting another function as denotation allow for certain u...
متن کاملDetailed Proof of Theorem 4.1 in Sense and Denotation as Algorithm and Value
§4. Sense identity and indirect reference. Van Heijenoort [30] quotes an extensive passage from a 1906 letter from Frege to Husserl which begins with the following sentence: “It seems to me that we must have an objective criterion for recognizing a thought as the same thought, since without such a criterion a logical analysis is not possible.” This could be read as asserting the existence of a ...
متن کامل